Health Violations Found CA 8 HEALTH VIOLATIONS

Pine Valley Mutual Wc

EPA ID: CA3710039 · 2,645 people served · 2 ZIP codes

Based on the latest federal compliance data, Pine Valley Mutual Wc has 12 violations that the EPA has not yet closed — those outstanding findings are part of the enforcement record for a utility that delivers water to approximately 2,645 people throughout its service territory.

Data: EPA SDWIS Last verified: 2026-04-02

C · 56
Avg Safety Score
2,645
People Served
2
ZIP Codes Served
12
Violations (5yr)
Groundwater
Water Source
0.0994 mg/L
Max Lead Level — Exceeds Limit
Zone 3
Radon Risk · Low
2
Contaminants Flagged
$385K
Median Home Value in Service Area

Compliance Trajectory

Worsening · Risk tier: High · 95% chance of violation in next 12 months

Violations went from 2 (2023) to 6 (2025). The pattern suggests growing compliance challenges.

Service Area Map

Coverage area for Pine Valley Mutual Wc Source: EPA SDWIS service area boundaries.

Service area boundary — Grade C

Service Area Demographics

$140,270
Median Household Income
2,580
Service Area Population
25%
Disadvantaged Population
40th
Poverty Percentile
20th
Energy Burden Percentile
75%
Pre-1986 Housing

The Pine Valley Mutual Wc serves a community with a median household income of $140,270 and an estimated 2,580 residents across its service area. Approximately 75% of housing stock was built before 1986, which increases the likelihood of lead service lines and older plumbing.

💧 Where Does Your Water Come From?

Groundwater

Pine Valley Mutual Wc's water is pumped from underground aquifers. Groundwater is naturally filtered through rock and soil, but it can be vulnerable to PFAS contamination, nitrates from agriculture, and industrial chemicals that seep into the water table.

Elevated Risk
Source Contamination Risk
30th
Wastewater Discharge Proximity
20th
Superfund Site Proximity

About 1% of homes in San Diego County, California rely on private wells rather than public water systems. Private well owners are responsible for their own water testing and treatment.

Infrastructure Risk

43 yr
Avg Pipe Age
Copper
Pipe Material
27 yr
Est. Remaining Life
Moderate Wear
Decay Status
Installed 61% of expected lifespan used End of life

Detected Contaminants

How Pine Valley Mutual Wc compares to EPA limits

Combined Radium 9 pCi/L (EXCEEDS LIMIT)
0 EPA Limit: 5 pCi/L

What This Means For You

Gross Alpha at 3 pCi/L exceeds the EPA maximum of pCi/L. Increased cancer risk from radioactive particles. Consider reverse osmosis filtration.

Combined Radium at 9 pCi/L exceeds the EPA maximum of 5 pCi/L.

Gross Alpha was detected in this water system. reverse osmosis filtration can reduce exposure.

Find a certified water filter →

Comparable Water Systems

Similar-sized systems in California

0 violations
0 violations
B 2 violations
City of Weed
2,662 people
C 0 violations
F 9 violations

Estimated Remediation Costs

Average estimated costs across ZIP codes served by this system

Lead Pipe Replacement Flood Insurance Water Filtration
Lead Pipe Replacement $4,680
Flood Insurance $1,200
Water Filtration $600
Total Estimated Cost $6,480

Based on national averages for common remediation projects. Actual costs vary by property. Only issues flagged by EPA, FEMA, or state data for each ZIP code are included.

Cost of Inaction

If water quality issues in this service area are not addressed, the estimated financial impact per household is:

Estimated Healthcare Costs $1,000

Annual per household (CDC est.)

Lead Exposure — Child Lifetime Cost $10,000

Per affected child (EPA est.)

Estimated Property Value Decline $19,255

5% of median home value (EPA est.)

Estimated Cumulative Cost Per Household

5 years
$17,410
10 years
$34,820
20 years
$69,640

Compare: Estimated remediation cost is $6,480 (one-time) vs. $34,820 in estimated inaction costs over 10 years.

Estimates based on published EPA, CDC, and peer-reviewed research. Individual costs vary by household size, property, and health factors. These are conservative lower-bound estimates intended for awareness, not financial advice.

System Overview

PINE VALLEY MUTUAL WC (EPA ID: CA3710039) is a community water system in California that serves approximately 2,645 people from groundwater sources.

This system provides water to 2 ZIP codes across 2 communities.

Average Home Safety Score: C (56/100)

Based on water quality violations, lead levels, and radon risk across all ZIP codes served by this system.

Violation History

8 health-based violations recorded in the past 5 years. 12 remain unresolved.

Recent Violations

Date Contaminant Type Status
July 1, 2025 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
April 1, 2025 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
January 1, 2025 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
October 1, 2024 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
July 1, 2024 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
April 1, 2024 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
April 1, 2024 Combined Radium Monitoring Unresolved
January 1, 2024 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
January 1, 2024 Gross Alpha Monitoring Unresolved
October 1, 2023 Combined Radium Health-based Unresolved
October 1, 2023 Gross Alpha Monitoring Unresolved
July 1, 2023 Gross Alpha Monitoring Unresolved

Contaminants Detected

The following contaminants have been flagged in EPA records for this water system:

Contaminant Category Violations Health-Based
Combined Radium Radionuclides 9 Yes
Gross Alpha Radionuclides 3 No

Lead & Copper

EPA Lead and Copper Rule sampling data for ZIP codes served by this system:

ZIP Code Lead Level Exceeds Limit Sample Date
91962 0.0994 mg/L Yes N/A
Lead exceeds EPA action level in at least one sampling location. Consider using a certified NSF/ANSI 53 or NSF/ANSI 58 filter rated for lead removal.

Radon Risk in Service Area

Dominant radon zone for ZIP codes served by this system: Zone 3 (Low Risk)

Need help with your water quality?

Typical cost: Water test: typically $20–$50 (DIY kit) · Professional inspection: $150–$400

Find the Right Water Filter

Free tip: Let cold water run for 2 minutes before drinking — this helps flush lead from your pipes.

ZIP Codes Served

Data Sources

This report uses public data from the EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System (SDWIS). View the full compliance record for Pine Valley Mutual Wc (CA3710039) on EPA.gov.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pine Valley Mutual Wc water safe to drink?

Pine Valley Mutual Wc has recorded 8 health-based violations in the past 5 years. While the system is required to treat water to meet federal standards, you may want to consider additional precautions such as a certified water filter.

How many people does Pine Valley Mutual Wc serve?

Pine Valley Mutual Wc serves approximately 2,645 people across 2 ZIP codes in California.

Where does Pine Valley Mutual Wc get its water?

The primary water source is groundwater.

Contact Your Water Utility

Public-record contact information for the water utility serving this system. Use these channels to request water quality reports, ask about service, or report issues directly.

Phone
619-473-8450
ZipCheckup is not affiliated with this water utility, does not act as its agent, and does not provide customer support for it. Contact details shown are public-record information from CCR filings. For service issues, contact the utility directly using the information above.
Address
28789 Old Highway 80, Pine Valley, CA 91962

Contact information from Pine Valley Mutual Water Company Consumer Confidence Report.

ZipCheckup is not affiliated with this water utility, does not act as its agent, and does not provide customer support for it. Contact details shown are public-record information from CCR filings. For service issues, contact the utility directly using the information above.

Water Source & Treatment

Where this water originates and how it's treated before reaching your tap.

Source
Groundwater
Drawn from underground aquifers via wells.
Disinfectant used
Chlorine
Treatment chemicals reported
chlorine

Source: Pine Valley Mutual Water Company Consumer Confidence Report.

ZipCheckup is not affiliated with this water utility. Treatment and source data are sourced from the utility's published CCR filings.

Source water assessment from Pine Valley Mutual Water Company Consumer Confidence Report:
A vulnerability assessment of the ground water sources was completed in June, 2001. The sources are considered most vulnerable to high density septic systems within Zone A for Well #4; agricultural and water supply wells in Zone A for Well #6; and agricultural wells in Zone B5 (five-year time of travel) for Well #7. Nitrates have historically been found in Well #1, #4, #5 and #10. These nitrate levels may be attributed to the septic systems in the area and perhaps to agricultural activities. A historic gas station with a confirmed leaking underground tank that was removed in December, 1999 is within Well #2 and #8's Zone A (two-year time of travel).

Treatment regime

How this utility classifies its treatment process and what each reported treatment chemical does.

Treatment classification
Standard
Disinfection plus one or more treatment additives — typically corrosion control, pH adjustment, or fluoridation. Standard regime for utilities serving treated municipal water.

Treatment chemicals and what each one does

Chemical names are reported verbatim by the utility. Purpose categories are ZipCheckup annotations based on standard drinking-water treatment practice.

Disinfectant
Inactivates bacteria, viruses, and parasites in the treated water.
chlorine

Watershed exposure sources reported

Land-use and natural conditions identified in the utility's source-water assessment as potential contamination sources upstream of treatment.

AgricultureSeptic systemsHistoric gas station with leaking underground tank

Treatment classification and chemical list sourced from Pine Valley Mutual Water Company Consumer Confidence Report.

Treatment intensity is a ZipCheckup-derived classification based on the chemicals and processes the utility reports. Chemicals and contamination sources are taken verbatim from the utility's CCR filing. Routine federal monitoring and contaminant testing shown elsewhere on this page determine whether the water meets safety standards, not the treatment classification.

Lead Service Line Inventory

Service line breakdown reported under the federal Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (LCRI) inventory requirement:

0
Confirmed Lead
0
Galvanized — Replacement Required
0
Unknown Material
704
Confirmed Non-Lead

This system reports zero confirmed lead service lines in its inventory. Unknown-material counts may still warrant verification.

Federal LCRI rule (effective October 2024) requires every public water system to inventory its service lines and complete lead-line replacement within 10 years.

Federal Regulatory Status · 2026Q1
LCRR inventory submission: Reported all required service line types
Latest tap sample on 2023-01-01 did not exceed the federal lead action level.
Population served: 2,645
Reported to California

Source: EPA SDWIS Federal Service Line Inventory (Phase 2) · Submitted 2026

ZipCheckup is not affiliated with the utility or state agency. Inventory figures render verbatim from the public LCRI submission cited above; ZipCheckup does not perform inspections or replacements.

Learn about lead in drinking water →

Aesthetic water quality

These measurements describe the look, taste, and feel of the water this utility delivers. They are not contaminant violations — they sit alongside federal Secondary Maximum Contaminant Levels (SMCLs) which the EPA publishes as non-enforceable guidance.

pH
7.53
How acidic or basic the water is on a 0-14 scale. Drinking water is typically near neutral.
EPA secondary range: 6.5 – 8.5
Fluoride
1.24 ppm
Utility adds fluoride
Measured fluoride concentration in parts per million.
EPA secondary MCL: 2.0 ppm
Alkalinity
188.57 ppm CaCO₃
Capacity of the water to neutralize acids, expressed as calcium carbonate equivalent.
Total dissolved solids
484.29 ppm
Mineral content remaining after evaporation, including calcium, magnesium, sodium, and other dissolved substances.
EPA secondary MCL: 500 ppm

Aesthetic measurements from Pine Valley Mutual Water Company Consumer Confidence Report.

Aesthetic measurements are reported by the utility from its annual sampling. EPA Secondary MCLs are advisory thresholds — values outside them indicate aesthetic concerns such as taste or appearance, not health violations. Federal contaminant testing is shown in the sections above.

Hard water detected in Pine Valley Mutual Water Company

Your utility reported water hardness of 271.43 ppm CaCO₃ (15.9 grains per gallon) in its most recent Consumer Confidence Report. This is in the very hard range and may cause scale buildup, reduced appliance lifespan, and dry skin or hair.

Solutions for hard water

There are three common approaches to treating hard water: salt-based ion-exchange softeners (most effective, require salt refills), salt-free conditioners (lower maintenance, scale prevention only), and reverse osmosis at the kitchen sink (cooking and drinking water only). Aquasana, EcoWater, Pelican, and SpringWell are among the major US brands.

Recommended Aquasana system for your hardness level

Paid Partner. ZipCheckup earns commission on Aquasana purchases. We do not test water or verify product effectiveness for specific hardness levels — manufacturer claims are theirs alone. Consult a certified water-quality professional for personalized advice.

Hardness data parsed from this utility's most recent Consumer Confidence Report. Severity bands per USGS hard water classification.

Notable events and violations

This section summarizes events the utility chose to disclose in its most recent Consumer Confidence Report, plus any federal compliance violations the utility recorded against itself. Both lists are utility-authored — ZipCheckup does not audit, judge, or reorder them.

Federal compliance violations on record

These entries are taken verbatim from the utility's CCR violations section. EPA defines four broad violation categories: Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL), Treatment Technique (TT), Monitoring & Reporting (M&R), and Public Notification (PN).

  • monitoring · Disinfection Byproducts (TTHMs)
    2015-02
    Missed Sample Deadline of February 2015
  • monitoring · Disinfection Byproducts (HAA5)
    2015-02
    Missed Sample Deadline of February 2015

Violations record from Pine Valley Mutual Water Company Consumer Confidence Report.

Notable events from the utility's CCR

These bullet entries are the utility's own narration of operational, regulatory, or infrastructure events during the reporting period.

Notable events from Pine Valley Mutual Water Company Consumer Confidence Report:
  • Missed sample deadlines for Disinfection Byproducts (TTHMs) and (HAA5) in February 2015.

ZipCheckup note: items above reflect what the utility published in its most recent CCR. Federal violation records are also tracked separately by the EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System (SDWIS) — the SDWIS record is the authoritative federal source for any specific regulatory action.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is water from Pine Valley Mutual Wc safe to drink?
Pine Valley Mutual Wc has a C safety grade based on 12 recorded violations. Some contaminants may exceed EPA limits — independent testing is recommended.
What contaminants are in Pine Valley Mutual Wc's water?
Detected contaminants include Gross Alpha, Combined Radium. Each is compared against EPA maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) in the detailed breakdown above.
Should I use a water filter?
Given 2 contaminants above EPA limits, a certified water filter can provide an extra layer of protection. The best type depends on specific contaminants in your water.
How many people does Pine Valley Mutual Wc serve?
Pine Valley Mutual Wc serves approximately 2,645 people with drinking water across 2 ZIP codes.
What is Pine Valley Mutual Wc's water source?
Pine Valley Mutual Wc draws water from groundwater sources. Source type affects which contaminants are most likely to be present.
Is there lead in Pine Valley Mutual Wc's water?
The maximum detected lead level is 0.0994 mg/L. This exceeds the EPA action level of 0.015 mg/L. A lead-certified filter is recommended, especially for homes with young children.
What is the demographic profile of Pine Valley Mutual Wc's service area?
The Pine Valley Mutual Wc service area has a median household income of $140,270. Demographic data is sourced from the U.S. Census Bureau and EPA EJScreen.
Where does Pine Valley Mutual Wc get its water?
Pine Valley Mutual Wc's water is pumped from underground aquifers. Groundwater is naturally filtered through rock and soil, but it can be vulnerable to PFAS contamination, nitrates from agriculture, and industrial chemicals that seep into the water table. Based on violation history and environmental factors, the source contamination risk is currently elevated.

What You Can Do

1

Test your water

Home test kits can detect lead, bacteria, and other contaminants at your tap. Find the right filter →

2

Check your specific ZIP code

Water quality can vary within a system. View nearest ZIP report →

3

Contact your utility

Pine Valley Mutual Wc (EPA ID: CA3710039) — request the latest Consumer Confidence Report or ask about specific contaminants.

Home Water Systems California Pine Valley Mutual Wc

Get safety alerts for Pine Valley Mutual Wc, California

Free updates when EPA data changes for this area. No spam.

Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy.

Share This Page

X Facebook
Concerned about lead? Check your risk Free tool — no phone call required.