Is Utica, NY Safe to Buy? Home Safety Score 58/100
Score 58/100 · Risk: moderate · Water Grade B · Updated 2026-05-03
Utica has moderate risk. Some factors warrant attention during the home buying process.
Data: EPA SDWIS, FEMA NFIP, Census ACS, EPA Radon Zones Last verified: 2026-05-03
Neither at the low end nor pushing into critical equity territory, the remediation range in Utica occupies a moderate position — a realistic planning figure that warrants attention without signaling financial alarm.
What is a home safety score?
The home safety score (0-100) combines multiple environmental risk factors into a single number: water quality grade, lead contamination levels, flood zone exposure, radon risk, and air quality. A higher score means lower overall risk. The score helps homebuyers compare neighborhoods at a glance. Utica scores 58/100 with a "moderate" risk level.
What is the equity trap ratio?
The equity trap ratio measures estimated remediation costs as a percentage of median home value. A high ratio (above 5%) means fixing environmental issues could consume a significant portion of your home equity — a potential "trap" for buyers unaware of hidden costs. Utica's equity trap ratio is 1.4%.
Remediation Cost Breakdown
Estimated costs to address safety issues for a typical home in Utica:
Cost ranges are estimates based on national averages. Actual costs vary by property. Get 3 quotes before proceeding.
Per-ZIP Home Safety Scores
Safety scores vary across Utica's 6 ZIP codes.
| ZIP Code | Score | Grade | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13504 | 56 | C | View report → |
| 13505 | 56 | C | View report → |
| 13599 | 56 | C | View report → |
| 13501 | 58 | C | View report → |
| 13502 | 58 | C | View report → |
| 13503 | 63 | C | View report → |
Home Safety Overview
Utica, New York has moderate risk for homebuyers. The average home safety score is 58/100 across 6 ZIP codes. Some risk factors warrant attention during the home buying process.
Safety Score Card
A composite view of Utica's key risk indicators:
| Risk Factor | Value | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Water Quality | Grade B (72/100) | Low risk |
| Lead Risk | 0.0120 mg/L | Moderate risk |
| Flood Risk | 50% in flood zones | Elevated risk |
| Radon | Zone 3 (Low) | Low risk |
| Air Quality | AQI 0 (Unknown) | Low risk |
Cost to Fix: Remediation Breakdown
Estimated costs to address safety issues for a typical home in Utica:
| Component | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|
| Filtration | $600 |
| Flood Insurance | $817 |
| Pfas | $83 |
| Total (low estimate) | $917 |
| Total (mid estimate) | $2K |
| Total (high estimate) | $3K |
Cost ranges are estimates based on national averages and local data. Actual costs vary by property condition, contractor, and scope of work. Get 3 quotes before proceeding.
Per-ZIP Home Safety Scores
Home safety varies across Utica's ZIP codes. Lower scores indicate more risk factors:
Utica vs. Nearby New York Cities
How Utica's overall risk compares to similar cities in New York:
| City | Water Grade | Lead ZIPs Over Limit | Flood Claims | Population |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Utica | B | 0 | 84 | 126,400 |
| Yorkville | C | 0 | 21 | 126,250 |
| Queens Village | C | 0 | 29 | 120,143 |
| Bellerose | B | 0 | 6 | 120,000 |
Homebuyer Safety Checklist for Utica
Before purchasing a home in Utica, New York, complete these checks:
Water Quality
- Request the latest Consumer Confidence Report (CCR) from the water utility
- Test tap water for lead, bacteria, and nitrates ($20-$50 for DIY kit)
Radon
- Conduct a radon test ($15-$30 for short-term kit, $150-$300 for professional)
Flood Risk
- Check the property's FEMA flood zone at msc.fema.gov
- Ask about flood history and past insurance claims
- 50% of Utica is in flood zones — verify insurance requirements
Lead Paint & Pipes
- For homes built before 1978: request lead paint disclosure
- For homes built before 1986: inspect plumbing for lead solder and pipes
- 90% of Utica homes built before 1986 — pipe inspection recommended
General
- Check for carbon monoxide detectors on every level
- Inspect for visible mold, water stains, or musty odors
- Verify the home's connection to a regulated public water system
Data Sources
- Water quality: EPA SDWIS
- Lead: EPA Lead and Copper Rule
- Flood: FEMA NFIP
- Radon: EPA Radon Zones
- Air quality: EPA AirNow
- Home values: U.S. Census Bureau ACS B25077
- Remediation costs: National cost model (EPA, Census, FEMA data)
Updated daily.
Water Quality Map: Utica, NY
Each dot represents a ZIP code. Color indicates water quality grade. Tap a dot for details.
Check your specific ZIP code
City averages can hide neighborhood-level risks. Enter your ZIP for a personalized home safety score.
Check Your Home Safety Score